

EVERYTHING SYNTH
Note: comments that insult people will be removed. Critique on gear is allowed. Do not ask if listings are still available. Click through auction links to check yourself. Posts and pics remain for historical purposes. To reduce spam, comments for posts older than one week are not displayed until approved (usually same day).
well, it does seem that Roland's intellectual property has been breached many times already, I'm surprised it has taken this long. The 808 and 909 sounds almost seem to be public domain now. :¬\
ReplyDeleteThe sounds weren't copyrighted, the logo, name and likeness were.
ReplyDeleteAsk Behringer.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteCan the D-16 do a good banjo?
ReplyDeleteThis seems really silly to me.
ReplyDeleteI am not a lawyer, but I can't imagine what grounds Roland could possibly have for this.
d16 have not used Roland's name or logo (at least not on any screenshots i've seen)
You don't need permission to emulate a product using a different technique.
Is there any LEGAL claim that can be made over 'likeness'? Perhaps with issue of trademarked logos but not front panel artwork.
Does anyone know for sure of what law they could be infringing?
Didn't Behringer get into trouble for copying patented circuit designs. That is a different scenario to d16.
I'd just take any mention of Roland out of any advertising blurbs and just say something like 'Emulates classic analog drum machines of the past'
What about Apple vs. Microsoft in the big 'Windows look and feel' case?
ReplyDeleteLook and feel shouldn't count, or is that only in GUI's vs. physical interfaceS?
link:
ReplyDeletehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_v._Microsoft
My guess is that it's a marketing strategy!
ReplyDeleteStrangely, they've put back the original picture for the 909 clone.
It is illegal to make products that look so close to another that the buyer could reasonably be confused.
ReplyDeleteBehringer was sued for their "Boss pedals" on looks alone.
Interesting. The 909 picture is actually different than the original. It used to have the same color scheme as the 909. Looks like they are updating the graphics on them and the 808 will follow.
ReplyDeleteWhy is the Ultravox video now a chick in dance tights?
ReplyDeleteWhere did the comments go?